CLEVELAND, Ohio — Cleveland police could wait longer for DNA, ballistics and drug test results next year if the city and Cuyahoga County cannot agree on what Cleveland should pay to use the county’s crime lab, cleveland.com reported.
The evidence at issue is processed by the Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, part of the Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner’s Office. The city recently increased its contract with the lab to $500,000 for this year, but those negotiations took nine months, and Hugh Shannon of the Medical Examiner’s Office told the county’s Board of Control this week that the county accepted the offer only so it could get “at least some revenue” for the year, cleveland.com reported.
The amount “was not deemed sufficient” for future years, Shannon told the Board of Control, according to cleveland.com. The county rejected a proposal to extend the contract through 2027 even though the extension came with another increase, to $522,500. “The amounts were not suitable to the administration or Dr. Gilson so we are negotiating for 2027,” Shannon told the board, referring to Medical Examiner Dr. Thomas Gilson, cleveland.com reported.
The current contract ends December 31, 2026. Neither city nor county officials answered questions from cleveland.com about what a lapse would mean for Cleveland investigations, or whether the city would be cut off from the lab on January 1, 2027. The county kept testing the city’s evidence during this year’s nine months of negotiations, cleveland.com reported.
If Cleveland loses access, Shannon suggested to the Board of Control, the city would have to send all of its evidence to the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation for processing, cleveland.com reported. Turnaround times at the state bureau, according to information from BCI cited by cleveland.com, range from a couple of days for basic searches to as long as 307 days for tests that measure the contents of a substance — a timeline that could slow cases ranging from drug prosecutions to rape-kit testing.
The county lab is budgeted to cost $9.1 million in 2027, according to county documents cited by cleveland.com. The lab provides testing services to nearly all law enforcement agencies in Cuyahoga County, Communications Director Kelly Woodard confirmed to cleveland.com, which makes Cleveland — the county’s largest city and its biggest source of cases — the customer the lab can least afford to lose, and the customer with the most to lose if the talks fail.
Cleveland argues it has been paying more, and more willingly, than the county acknowledges. City spokesman Tyler Sinclair told cleveland.com that Cleveland originally paid $200,000 a year for testing services, increased the amount to $300,000 in 2017, and that City Council agreed to raise the payment again to $500,000, understanding that inflation has raised costs nationwide. He called the increase a “fair, but still significant adjustment” that came with another bump next year to $522,500, and noted that Council approved the agreement on October 19, 2026, cleveland.com reported.
“The City’s flexibility and willingness to come to the negotiation table with an open mind is what good governmental partnerships are all about,” Sinclair told cleveland.com. “We remain hopeful that the County recognizes this and that we’ll soon reach an agreement for 2027.”
Shannon, however, called the city’s prior agreement a “sweetheart deal” and said the county expects more compensation going forward, cleveland.com reported. He did not put a public price on what amount above $500,000 the county would consider fair.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on
What is confirmed, from the Board of Control discussion and the statements reported by cleveland.com, is the shape of the dispute: a $500,000 contract for this year, a rejected extension at $522,500 for 2027, a county lab budgeted at $9.1 million, and a December 31, 2026 deadline. What is not yet established is the county’s asking price, whether the lab would actually stop accepting Cleveland evidence on January 1, 2027, and how much evidence Cleveland sends to the lab in a typical year — the number that would determine how hard a shift to the state bureau would hit investigations.
What happens next: the two sides keep negotiating for a 2027 agreement before the current contract expires on December 31, 2026. If no deal is reached, Cleveland’s fallback, as Shannon described it to the Board of Control, is the state Bureau of Criminal Investigation — and the turnaround times cleveland.com cited suggest detectives and prosecutors would feel that change in case after case through 2027.




[…] its summer 2028 opening. The financing round lands in a busy month for Cleveland institutions, from the county crime lab dispute affecting Cleveland police evidence to Akron’s record-setting Magnus Cup swim meet in Cleveland this […]