Hundreds of provisional ballots cast in Hamilton County will not be counted unless a court orders them counted, after the Hamilton County Board of Elections split again on Friday, November 20, 2026, and Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose said he cannot break the tie, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
The 740 ballots at issue were cast by voters who moved into Hamilton County from other Ohio counties and did not update their voter registration before the election, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. The voters cast provisional ballots at their polling locations rather than at the county board of elections office, and whether Ohio law allows those ballots to count is the question that has divided the board along party lines.
Democratic board members Alex Linser, who also chairs the Hamilton County Democratic Party, and Joe Mallory believe the votes should be counted, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. Republican board members Alex Triantafilou, who also chairs the Ohio Republican Party, and Chip Gerhardt think they should be rejected. Triantafilou said at the board’s November 17, 2026 meeting that he believes Ohio law means voters who move into a county have to vote at the board of elections rather than at their polling location, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
The board first split 2-2 on November 17, 2026, and sent the question to LaRose. In letters sent to election officials on November 20, 2026, LaRose declined to decide it. "Because I find that this matter is not suitable for a tie-vote determination, I will not issue a substantive decision," LaRose wrote, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer. LaRose’s office advised county boards that they must vote 3-1 to count those ballots — and that if a board is split, the ballots will not be counted, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. LaRose also suggested the boards keep an eye on the Ohio Supreme Court, which is reviewing a legal challenge from a Republican state legislative candidate in Lucas County over the same category of ballots, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
Hamilton County’s board then met in an emergency session on November 20, 2026. Linser motioned to approve the ballots but keep them separated in case of a court decision, but the board voted 2-2 along party lines, meaning the ballots will not be counted, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. "This controversy is happening on boards throughout the state, and everywhere else, the Republican board members voted with the Democrats to count the ballots, and so we are an anomaly," Linser said, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer, adding that he is "not comfortable with Hamilton County being on an island." Triantafilou said at the emergency meeting that he believes the issue has been resolved based on LaRose’s guidance and his own review of the Ohio laws in question, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
Hamilton County is not the only board in this position. Election officials in Delaware County also split over the same category of ballots and asked LaRose to break the tie, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported: there, 583 provisional ballots are in dispute in a county commissioner race where Republican Renee Vaughan holds a narrow unofficial lead over Democrat Ryan Grissinger. Republicans asked election officials in six counties not to count ballots from voters who moved between Ohio counties and voted at a polling location, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
The Hamilton County fight lands on one of the closest legislative races in Ohio. Republican State Representative Cindy Abrams of Harrison leads Democrat Jonathan Bradner by just 19 votes in unofficial results in House District 29, which includes parts of Harrison, Mount Healthy and North College Hill, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported — a margin inside the range that triggers an automatic recount. Abrams was appointed to the seat in 2019 and has never had a race this tight, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. Bradner attended the board’s November 20, 2026 meeting and said he is "extremely disappointed" for the 740 people whose votes will not be counted, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer. The board does not know how many of the 740 ballots are in District 29, because staff cannot open the provisional envelopes until a decision is made, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on: Confirmed by the Cincinnati Enquirer’s reporting are the two 2-2 votes, LaRose’s refusal to break the tie and his office’s 3-1 guidance, and the present consequence: the 740 ballots stay uncounted unless a court orders otherwise. What is still open is the Ohio Supreme Court’s Lucas County case, which could settle the underlying legal question for every county, and any court challenge filed over the Hamilton County ballots themselves before certification.
The immediate effect of Friday’s vote is administrative: board staff can now open and begin counting the roughly 8,000 provisional ballots that were not rejected, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. What happens next is certification — the deadline to certify the election results is Tuesday, November 24, 2026, and the board will meet at 10:00 AM that day at its office at 4700 Smith Road in Norwood, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported. If the Abrams margin holds inside the recount range, an automatic recount follows certification.



