Accessibility:
Text size
Sat. Nov 21st, 2026
Anthony Wayne Bridge and the Toledo skyline over the Maumee RiverThe Anthony Wayne Bridge and the Toledo skyline over the Maumee River. Photo: Limpfster94, CC BY-SA

Toledo City Council will consider a $50,000 settlement with a former Toledo Fire & Rescue lieutenant who was fired over an off-duty Facebook comment about the assassination of Charlie Kirk and then sued the city, claiming his firing violated his First Amendment rights. The city Law Department has proposed an ordinance authorizing the payment, and a first reading of the settlement ordinance is set for Tuesday, November 24, 2026, before City Council, 13 Action News (WTVG) reported.

The former lieutenant is Jeffery Schroeder, who served 28 years with the Toledo Fire and Rescue Department and 35 years with the City of Toledo, according to his federal complaint, summarized by the Fire Law Blog. Schroeder alleges he posted the comment from his personal account while off duty and on vacation in September 2025, before he learned that Kirk had died from the shooting, and that the post stayed online for about 30 minutes before it was deleted at the fire chief’s request, conveyed through the union president, the Fire Law Blog reported from the complaint.

The department’s internal investigation produced four administrative charges. After an administrative hearing on October 29, 2025, Fire Chief Allison Armstrong found Schroeder guilty of three of the four charges, including conduct unbecoming a lieutenant and two counts of violating the department’s social media policy, and he was fired, according to a department press release obtained by WTOL and reported by FireRescue1. The department said the firing was consistent with its zero-tolerance policy for conduct that promotes violence, disrupts operations or harms the department’s reputation, FireRescue1 reported.

The backlash around the post was immediate. Toledo Fire & Rescue placed all of its firehouses on a precautionary lockdown in September 2025 amid the online reaction, WTVG reported at the time, and Schroeder’s complaint alleges the department received approximately 1,000 complaints from members of the public, according to the Fire Law Blog.

Schroeder sued the city, the fire chief, the city’s safety director and several command officers in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, alleging retaliatory termination, an unconstitutional custom or policy, and wrongful termination, the Fire Law Blog reported from the complaint. The city has not admitted those claims; the proposed settlement, if council approves it, would resolve the lawsuit without a court ruling on the constitutional questions the case raises about how a public fire department may discipline employees for off-duty social media speech.

For Toledo taxpayers, an approved settlement would commit $50,000 in city funds to close the case. The ordinance needs council approval before any payment is authorized, 13 Action News (WTVG) reported.

What happens next: the settlement ordinance gets its first reading before Toledo City Council on Tuesday, November 24, 2026. Council members will decide whether to authorize the $50,000 payment and end the lawsuit, or to let the federal case proceed toward a ruling on Schroeder’s First Amendment claims.

Photo: Limpfster94, CC BY-SA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *